Home > Analysis, The Coalition > The Papal Visit

The Papal Visit

Why is the Pope coming to The United Kingdom?

With the impending Papal visit I have come to consider why the Pope is coming here. This is the first papal visit in nearly three decades. Now while John Paul II, who was undoubtedly a bit of a rebel Pope was the previous Pope to visit, there has not been a papal visit since Henry VIII got angry because his wife was getting on a bit. Now while I understand that the Popes between Henry VIII and George IV may have feared being burnt, thankfully we have moved on since then.

There must have been a reason that from 1829 and the Catholic Emancipation Act that no Pope decided to come to our fabled shores. The UK would seem the perfect place to try conversion of other Christians, Christians who are born into a state religion as opposed to the ‘freedom’ of being a Catholic. It would seem that there is some other reason for the Popes of the past not coming here. Is it the fierce religious opposition of the population? I highly doubt it as a race 45% of us say that we have no religion. This would again seem a good reason for a Pope to visit the U.K. An adventurous Pope, which I know is a slightly oxymoronic, would I am sure wish not to travel to countries with large amounts of popular support but to seek out challenging areas where the message of Catholicism could be spread. So maybe this is the reason that Pope Benedict XVI is coming to our very un-catholic and unreligious land, but no he is coming to proclaim that a man who died in 1890 is someone who he believes, with great fervour I am sure, is in heaven and has the ear of god.

I am just going to take a little time here to have a sideways rant. While I myself am an atheist of the Dawkins breed, I am liberal enough to believe that anyone is free to believe in whatever they want even when I know they are wrong. On that note one of my main concerns with the incompatibility of religion and some sense of logic is this: Almost all religions claim that their deity is omnipotent and omniscient. This means that their deity is all powerful and all knowing. If that is true it means that the deity cannot change its mind because it already knows the path or choice it must take or make. Therefore why pray? Your deity has already decided whether or not they will do what you ask. This is just one of the logical fallacies that I believe help to disprove religion. Rant Over

Now I turn to the question of why the Pope is coming here or more specifically why is someone who has the same status as the leader of a country, not a large amount of misguided individuals, which I believe him to be, being invited on a state visit? Well Gordon Brown, who felt the need for a private audience with his holiness in February of 2009, extended a formal invitation for the Pope to visit the U.K. Gordon Brown, who as I have previously said was not even elected, invited a man who denies scientific fact to further the proliferation of Bronze Age myths to our country, for reasons that elude me. The leader of our country invited a high profile figure who speaks out directly against certain U.K. laws, notably gender equality, sexual freedom of the individual, as well as the condemnation of condoms in the fight against HIV/AIDs. Of course for any other world leader to say that the use of condoms helps the spread of HIV/AIDs would be deplored as ridiculous and dangerous, but because this man who was elected by fellow men not elevated by a deity claims that his deity would prefer it this way apparently that is ok. Just in case the Pope ever reads this, in the Glorious Revolution of 1688-1689 The United Kingdom began the ending of the Divine Rights of rulers and it is time the Papacy came forward by almost four hundred years. How can one be a moral leader when he believes people should be treated differently because of who they were born or choose to be?

Finally if you do not agree with my arguments of why the Pope should not be coming to our country, the majority of whose citizens he could not convert, because they have out grown the need for blinkers to understand the world they evolved in, do you agree that in this time when budgets are being cut left right and centre in the public sector, should the public be expected to foot the bill of a £15 million visit with the added security costs on top of that. The Pope has a plan for what happens after you die. No matter whom you voted for or even if you voted, at least the politicians we have are trying to solve the problems we have now and I hope none of them are praying for a solution because even if I were wrong it would not do them or more importantly us any good.

Advertisements
  1. August 24, 2010 at 10:54

    I think you’ve answered your own question. Benny 16 is coming because the PM (who, as you know is never elected) of Her Britanic Majesty, Defender of the Faith, invited him. I’m sure he would understand if the invitation was withdrawn for financial reasons.
    With regards to prayer, if the point of it was to bend Providence to suit the wishes of the worshipper

  2. August 24, 2010 at 11:14

    you seem to have missed the end of your comment and the bit about prayer is a logical joke myself and Mr Oldfield were sharing the other day and is more a sideline for him than for anything else. I understand that we do not elect a PM but a political party whose leader is then appointed to form a government on behalf of the monarch i think my meaning was clear that the leadership of the country changed with the approval of the public.

  3. August 24, 2010 at 12:20

    …sorry about that I pressed the wrong bit of the iphone and it submitted instead!

    I think Cameron & Clegg made it clear in the Bristol TV debate that the Papal Visit was a good thing in their opinion.

    My point about prayer was going to be that you appeared to misunderstand its purpose but perhaps that’s irrelevant as it was a joke.

    With regards to the cost of the security, perhaps those who wish to protest at the visit and want to perform a citizen’s arrest on Benny could fork out a few quid for that as they are adding significantly to the cost that they are complaining about.

    • August 24, 2010 at 13:33

      It is not planned to be a citizen’s arrest the CPS have received a letter from a barrister asking to begin criminal proceedings. just remember the institutionalised concealment of child rape is a crime under any law.

      • August 24, 2010 at 22:33

        You don’t deny that those who are planning to protest are adding significantly to the cost of the visit?

      • August 25, 2010 at 15:06

        not significantly the people planning to protest his visit will be a small number the police presence will be necessary to control the large number of people wishing to see him. so I don’t believe that there will be a significant number of people protesting.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: